Electricity vs. Gas Heating — Efficiency, Cost & CO₂
Heat Demand & Factors
System Efficiencies
Prices & Emission Factors
Advanced (optional)
Use the methane % to include a CO₂e uplift for gas supply (awareness-level). All factors are editable.
Friendly estimate only. Real homes vary with climate, setpoints, insulation, hot water draws, and equipment performance.
Results
How This Heating Comparison Works
You supply a heat demand (kWh of heat). Each system delivers that heat with its own efficiency: electric resistance ≈ 100%, heat pumps ≈ COP 2–4, and gas boilers ≈ 85–95%. We convert heat to required energy in, then multiply by your prices and emission factors.
- Heat pump electricity in: heat ÷ COP
- Electric resistance electricity in: heat ÷ (eff%)
- Gas energy in: heat ÷ (boiler eff%)
- CO₂: electricity kWh × grid kg/kWh; gas kWh × gas kg/kWh (optional upstream % adds proportionally)
Tip: Try COP 3.0 as a season average; colder days are lower, mild days higher.
FAQs
What should I enter for heat demand?
Use your best estimate. For daily space heat, try 20–60 kWh/day in winter for a typical home; for annual totals, use your past bills or an energy audit.
Why does the heat pump often win?
Heat pumps move heat instead of making it—so their COP can be 3+, meaning 1 kWh in ≈ 3 kWh of heat out.
Is gas factor exact?
No—0.184 kg/kWh is a common HHV-based tailpipe CO₂ figure. Regions differ; edit to match your source. You can add an upstream % if you want CO₂e awareness.