IRR assumes magical reinvestment
IRR quietly assumes interim cash flows are reinvested at the IRR itself—a big ask. NPV is honest about your chosen discount rate.
| # | Period (t) | Cash Flow | Action |
|---|
Tip: Investment at t=0 is usually negative. Enter any number of inflows/outflows.
NPV discounts each cash flow back to today and sums the results. Positive NPV means value created at your chosen discount rate.
IRR is the discount rate that makes NPV = 0. If cash-flow signs switch multiple times, multiple IRRs can exist; rely on NPV or MIRR in that case.
Net Present Value (NPV) and Internal Rate of Return (IRR) are two essential ways to judge whether an investment or project is worth doing. Both start from the same place—a list of cash flows over time (money out as negatives, money in as positives)—and both “time-weight” money to reflect the idea that £/$1 today is worth more than £/$1 later.
NPV discounts each cash flow back to today using a discount rate (often your required return or cost of capital) and then sums them up. If the result is positive, the project creates value above your required return; if it’s negative, it falls short. In short: choose projects with the highest positive NPV when capital is limited.
IRR is the annualised rate at which NPV equals zero. Think of it as the “average annual return” implied by your cash flows. A rule of thumb: if IRR exceeds your required return, the project clears the hurdle. If it’s lower, it doesn’t. IRR is intuitive for quick comparisons, while NPV is more reliable when projects differ in size or timing.
Common choices include your cost of capital, a target return, or a risk-adjusted rate for the project’s profile. Higher rates penalise distant cash flows more, lowering NPV. Not sure where to start? Many users try a base case (e.g., 8–12% annually) and run quick sensitivities.
Suppose you invest -1,000 today and expect +300, +400, and +500 over three periods. At a 10% annual discount rate, NPV is roughly -21 (slightly negative). The IRR comes out near ~9.7%. Since 9.7% is below 10%, the project just misses your hurdle.
IRR quietly assumes interim cash flows are reinvested at the IRR itself—a big ask. NPV is honest about your chosen discount rate.
Projects that flip sign more than once can have several IRRs—or none. NPV won’t get confused when the sign pattern gets weird.
IRR loves fast cash: a quick but tiny project can outrank a huge long-term winner. NPV adjusts for scale and timing.
A one-point rate change near breakeven can flip NPV’s sign. Always run ± sensitivities—especially when NPV hovers near zero.
If projects compete for the same budget, the highest IRR isn’t always best—the project with the biggest positive NPV wins value creation.